Home / Electric Vehicles / Electric Pick-Up Trucks Ranked: Isuzu D-Max EV Leads a Small but Growing Field

Electric Pick-Up Trucks Ranked: Isuzu D-Max EV Leads a Small but Growing Field

Electric pick-ups are having a moment, though not quite the one the optimists predicted. The passenger car market has raced ahead with dozens of battery-powered options, but the pick-up sector has moved at a crawl: range anxiety is magnified by the loads these vehicles are expected to carry, prices sit well above their diesel equivalents, and the choice remains stubbornly thin.

For business users, though, the case is compelling. A pick-up that qualifies as a commercial vehicle can be run through the business far more tax-efficiently than a passenger car, and for sole traders and fleets watching the bottom line, that can matter more than a few miles of range. The question is no longer whether electric pick-ups make sense, but which one makes the most sense. We have ranked the current crop by the metrics that matter most to buyers: payload, towing capacity, range and tax status.

A note on the tax point, because it is widely misunderstood. Benefit in Kind applies to company cars, not to commercial vehicles. A pick-up that qualifies as a commercial vehicle is instead subject to the flat van benefit charge for private use, and double-cab pick-ups have their own rules that have shifted in recent years. The D-Max EV’s advantage is that it is the only electric pick-up on sale that qualifies as a commercial vehicle, which unlocks VAT reclaim and Capital Allowances treatment that no rival can match. If you are buying through a business, check your own circumstances with an accountant before signing, because the double-cab rules are not always straightforward.

Isuzu D-Max EV: the one to beat

The Isuzu D-Max EV takes top honours, and the reason is straightforward: it is the only electric pick-up on sale that qualifies as a commercial vehicle. That distinction unlocks VAT reclaim and Capital Allowances advantages that no rival can match, making it the default choice for businesses running a fleet or sole traders watching the bottom line.

Isuzu did not simply drop a battery into the existing D-Max and hope for the best. The suspension was re-engineered to cope with the weight of the battery pack while still supporting a substantial payload. The Extended Cab manages 1,060kg, while the Double Cab comes in at 1,015kg. No other electric pick-up comes close to the 1,000kg threshold; the next most capable is hundreds of kilos behind. Braked towing capacity stands at 3,500kg, matching the diesel D-Max and equalling the best in this group.

The trade-offs are real, though. Range sits at 163 miles on the WLTP cycle, which is modest by any standard, and the maximum charging rate of 50kW means a 20 to 80 per cent recharge takes a full hour. Ditching the diesel engine does make for a more relaxing drive, and the D-Max EV rides quite well, but the £20,000 premium over the diesel version will give many buyers pause. Its appeal is likely to remain fairly niche, but for those who can justify the cost, it is the most complete electric pick-up available.

Toyota Hilux BEV: off-road prowess, on-road polish

The Toyota Hilux BEV carries a legendary nameplate into the electric era, and it does so with a blend of on-road competence and off-road ability that few rivals can touch. It is good to drive on the road and extremely able on tougher terrain, thanks in part to a 56.2kWh battery powering two motors, one per axle.

Toyota’s Multi-Terrain System continually adjusts motor responses to mimic a traditional locking differential and low-range gearbox, which means the Hilux BEV retains the go-anywhere character that has made the diesel version a favourite among farmers and outdoor enthusiasts. The 0-62mph sprint takes 9.9 seconds, two tenths quicker than the D-Max.

The compromises, however, are harder to overlook. Payload is around 300kg behind the Isuzu’s, and braked towing capacity of 1,600kg is nothing special for a vehicle of this size. Range is 150 miles on the WLTP cycle, even more modest than the D-Max’s, though rapid charging at 150kW is three times the Isuzu’s rate, which goes some way to offsetting the smaller battery. For buyers who prioritise off-road capability and the Toyota badge, the Hilux BEV makes a strong case. For those who need to carry or tow heavy loads, it falls short.

KGM Musso EV: the value champion

The KGM Musso EV is the outlier in this group, and that is meant as a compliment. It was built from the ground up for electric power, unlike the Toyota and Isuzu, which were adapted from combustion-first designs. It is unrelated to the diesel Musso, which allows for a much larger battery pack: 80.6kWh in total, delivering an official WLTP range of up to 249 miles. We would expect a real-world figure closer to 200 miles, though we have not yet tested it independently.

That range advantage is significant, particularly for buyers who need to cover longer distances between charges. Payload sits at 690kg, further behind the Isuzu, and towing capacity of 2,300kg is better than the Toyota’s but still some way short of the D-Max. What sets the Musso EV apart, though, is its price. It is by far the cheapest electric pick-up on sale, a major draw for businesses looking to electrify without breaking the bank.

The Musso EV also arrives with no KGM badges on the bodywork, a curious decision that suggests the brand is still finding its identity in this space. Regardless, the value proposition is compelling, and for many buyers it will be the most sensible entry point into electric pick-up ownership.

Maxus eTerron9: big battery, big power, big compromises

The Maxus eTerron9 arrives with the largest battery in this group, a 102kWh pack that delivers a best-in-class range of 269 miles on the WLTP cycle. It is also the most powerful by far, with 436bhp on tap, and it matches the Isuzu’s 3,500kg towing capacity. On paper, it looks like the pick-up to beat.

In practice, the eTerron9 is a mixed bag. Payload is the least impressive here at 620kg, and the ride and handling are poor, particularly for a vehicle at this price point. The maximum charge rate of 115kW is mediocre given the size of the battery, meaning stops will be longer than the figures might suggest. It is also expensive, which makes the dynamic shortcomings harder to forgive.

Where the eTerron9 does shine is in its practical touches. A large weatherproof frunk with 236 litres of storage is genuinely useful, and vehicle-to-load capability means it can power tools or equipment on site, a feature that will appeal to tradespeople. For buyers who prioritise range and power above all else, and who can live with the compromises, the eTerron9 has its merits. For everyone else, the D-Max and Musso offer a more balanced package.

The verdict: D-Max EV wins overall, Musso EV wins on value

The Isuzu D-Max EV is the best electric pick-up on sale today. Its unique status as a commercial vehicle for tax purposes, combined with a payload that no rival can match and a towing capacity that equals the best in the group, makes it the clear choice for businesses and sole traders. The range and charging limitations are real, but for many buyers, the financial advantages will outweigh them.

The KGM Musso EV is the value champion, offering the best real-world range in the group at a price that undercuts the competition significantly. It is the pick-up for buyers who want to electrify without spending a fortune.

The Toyota Hilux BEV and Maxus eTerron9 suit more specific needs. The Hilux is the off-road specialist, with genuine capability and a rapid charging rate that makes the most of its smaller battery. The eTerron9 is the range and power leader, with practical features that will appeal to tradespeople, provided they can live with the poor ride and high price.

Electric pick-ups remain a niche choice, and the compromises are real. But for the right buyer, the case is getting stronger. As more models arrive and the charging infrastructure improves, expect this field to grow. For now, the D-Max EV leads the pack, and it will take a serious effort from rivals to knock it off its perch.

Tagged:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *