Home / News / Kia Sportage vs Jeep Compass: Can Jeep’s New Family SUV Take On The Class Leader?

Kia Sportage vs Jeep Compass: Can Jeep’s New Family SUV Take On The Class Leader?

Photo of a Modern Kia Sportage SUV

Price and positioning: a narrow gap with big consequences

The Compass starts at just under £35,000 and climbs to nearly £48,000 at the top of the range. The Sportage opens at £31,400 and tops out at £48,000 for the four-wheel-drive plug-in hybrid. Kia undercuts Jeep by roughly £3,600 at the entry point, and that gap matters in a class where buyers shop with a spreadsheet as much as their heart.

Jeep’s standard no-cost colour is Hawaii Green, which is a genuinely appealing touch, but every other metallic finish adds £800, and a contrast black roof costs £1,200 even if you stick with the standard hue. The Sportage’s Storm special edition bundles metallic paint in grey, dark grey or black as standard, which makes the Kia’s value case easier to defend once you start ticking boxes.

Powertrains and performance: torque versus outright pace

The Compass is offered as an electric model, a plug-in hybrid and a hybrid, and it was the front-wheel-drive hybrid that we drove. It is less powerful than the equivalent Sportage hybrid and nearly 2.5 seconds slower from 0 to 62mph. That sounds damning until you drive it, because strong mid-range torque means it rarely feels sluggish in the way the stopwatch suggests. The gearbox, however, dislikes being rushed, so smooth inputs are rewarded and hurried ones are not.

The Sportage counters with a broader line-up: hybrid, plug-in hybrid and mild-hybrid petrol, with no electric version in the range. Kia points buyers wanting a battery-only family SUV towards the EV5 instead. For most households the hybrid will be the sensible pick, and it delivers the sort of unflustered performance that suits school runs and motorway slogs alike.

On the road: composure wins the daily battle

This is where the two cars diverge most sharply. The Compass has an unsettled low-speed ride that harms its all-round ability, though it settles noticeably at higher speeds. Around town, over broken surfaces and speed humps, that fidgetiness is exactly the sort of flaw that wears thin on a daily commute.

The Sportage feels more mature, with neutral handling and a comfortable ride. It is not a car that invites you to seek out a B-road for fun, but it is composed, predictable and easy to live with. For a family SUV doing the school run, the supermarket trip and the occasional long haul, that neutrality is a virtue rather than a compromise.

Design and cabin character: heritage versus maturity

Jeep has leaned hard into its back catalogue, and some of the details are genuinely charming. There is a camping silhouette at the base of the windscreen, the Great Bear constellation beneath the rear-view mirror, the original Jeep on the wheel centre caps and the seven-bar grille motif repeated on the front bumper corner and the dashboard top. The third-generation Compass sits on the STLA platform shared with the Peugeot 3008, a big step from its predecessors, which shared their foundations with the Mitsubishi ASX and later the Fiat 500X.

The Sportage takes a different route. It feels more upmarket inside, and the nameplate carries more than 30 years of history, with the third generation from 2010 establishing it as a stylish SUV and sending sales soaring. The facelift at the end of last year sharpened the package further. The Storm edition, also offered on the EV5, adds a black interior with artificial leather seats and suede-effect upper sections, plus customisable ambient lighting on automatic models.

Practicality and equipment: where the Kia pulls clear

The Sportage’s equipment list is strong. Adjustable regenerative braking is included, with three levels running from heavy resistance to freewheeling and adjusted via steering-wheel paddles. That is a genuinely useful feature for anyone adapting to hybrid driving, and it is the kind of detail Kia has become good at. The Storm edition adds electrically adjustable heated and ventilated front seats, heated outer rear seats, an eight-speaker Harman Kardon system and unique 18-inch alloys.

The Compass counters with its design flourishes and the appeal of the Jeep badge, but it does not match that equipment roster item for item. For buyers cross-shopping on specification, the Kia makes the stronger argument.

Verdict: the Sportage stays ahead

The Compass is not without appeal. It looks the part, the heritage touches are well judged and that mid-range torque makes it more usable than its power deficit implies. But it asks more money at the entry point, rides poorly at low speed and cannot match the Kia on equipment or composure.

The Sportage remains the strong seller in this sector for exactly those reasons. It is comfortable, well equipped and easy to recommend, and the Storm edition adds enough kit to keep it fresh. The decision rule is simple: buy the Compass only if the styling, the badge and the no-cost green paint genuinely matter to you and you can live with a firm ride around town. If your priorities are comfort, kit and resale confidence, the Kia is the safer spend. Jeep’s line-up is thin at the moment, with the Wrangler gone from the price lists and the Compass and Avenger left to carry the brand, so the Compass needs to be a persuasive case on its own merits. On this showing, it is not quite there yet.

Related: jeep wrangler scrambler srt.

Tagged:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *